Wisconsin
Medicare plans in Lafayette County
2026 plan year. 35 Medicare plans available — 32 Medicare Advantage, 0 Part D, 3 Medigap, 9 D-SNP. Sourced from the CMS March 2026 Landscape file.
Carriers serving this county
10
5 Wisconsin-based
Average MA premium
$64/mo
15 plans at $0/mo
Top CMS Star rating
4.5 ★
Updated annually by CMS
Plan-count rank in WI
#44
of 73 counties
Top carriers in Lafayette County
- UnitedHealthcare11 plans
- Humana7 plans
- Aetna Medicare3 plansWI-based
- Medical Associates Clinic Health Plan of Wisconsin3 plans
- Multiple WI-approved carriers3 plans
Top-rated plans
Highest CMS Star ratings in Lafayette County. Tap for full plan detail.
- Aetna Medicare — Aetna Medicare Eagle (PPO)4.5$0/moMedicare Advantage · OOP max $4,900
- Aetna Medicare — Aetna Medicare Signature (PPO)4.5$0/moMedicare Advantage · OOP max $5,900
- Aetna Medicare — Aetna Medicare Premier (PPO)4.5$27/moMedicare Advantage · OOP max $5,200
- Humana — HumanaChoice H7617-007 (PPO)4.5$47/moMedicare Advantage · OOP max $9,250
- Humana — Humana USAA Honor Giveback (PPO)4.5$0/moMedicare Advantage · OOP max $6,000
- Medical Associates Clinic Health Plan of Wisconsin — Medical Associates SmartPlan (Cost)4.5$150/moMedicare Advantage · OOP max $0
Get a personalized ranking
Static stats are useful — but the right plan depends on your doctors, prescriptions, and priorities. Run the 5- minute questionnaire and we'll rank every plan in Lafayette County for you.
Start Medicare flowLooking for Medicaid / BadgerCare in Lafayette County? The eligibility screener checks every WI Medicaid program. ACA Marketplace shoppers, try the Marketplace flow.